« Welfare for All | Main | Poland Beats Back Abortion »

Religious Politicians

The startribune.com has an interesting comparison of views on the role of government as it relates to providing basic services for immigrants.

Here are excerpts of the two perspectives:

PERSPECTIVE 1

I believe that through heavy taxation (30 to 50 percent for most Americans), big and intrusive government actually hinders Christians' ability to give, leaving few available resources to help the poor. Instead, their income supports ever-expanding government bureaucracy and services through which its recipients become increasingly dependent upon the government; many are enslaved to the very system initially designed to liberate them.

PERSPECTIVE 2
Because human needs require it, and other resources are not available to meet those needs, we believe that it is right and proper to raise income taxes justly and equitably ... . We know [Minnesotans] are willing to sacrifice for their poor brothers and sisters facing difficult financial hardships. The taxes we pay today, and those paid by our parents and grandparents before us, have allowed us ... to develop and sustain a high quality of life [and] allow us to meet our moral responsibility toward our fellow citizens, our brothers and sisters in the family of God."

Now let's play match the perspective with the author.

POSSIBLE AUTHORS

A) The chair of the state democratic party
B) The chair of the state republican party
C) The head of a middle class household in Minnesota
D) A retired evangelical pastor
E) The local Catholic archbishop


Match the perspective with the author.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://aquaries.elinuxservers.com/~sage/movabletype/mt-tb.cgi/325

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Religious Politicians:

» wallpapers sexy from wallpapers sexy
wallpapers sexy [Read More]

» amature webmaster of fredrick maryland from glenn cadrez former football player dating brande roderick
kid student pen pals [Read More]

» kelly blue book value from kelly blue book value
kelly blue book value [Read More]

» indian dating from indian dating
indian dating [Read More]

» dating and singles websites from dating and singles websites
dating and singles websites [Read More]

» free dating websites from free dating websites
free dating websites [Read More]

» cheating cocksucking and fucking wives from adult dating link sites
100% free dating in usa [Read More]

» online dating from online dating
online dating [Read More]

» native americans from native americans
native americans [Read More]

» american red cross from american red cross
american red cross [Read More]

» Nancy Thomas from Paul Jackson
asian [Read More]

» mother s day from mother s day
mother s day [Read More]

» Patricia Johnson from Robert Williams
This is very interesting theme [Read More]

» makeovergames from makeovergames
makeovergames [Read More]

» cheep flights from Griffith
Nice post. I write something about cheep flights into my blog. [Read More]

» dna analysis from dna analysis
dna analysis [Read More]

» air ticket from air ticket
air ticket [Read More]

» wells fargo arena from wells fargo arena
wells fargo arena [Read More]

» england flowers from england flowers
england flowers [Read More]

» edmonton flowers from edmonton flowers
edmonton flowers [Read More]

» flower garden from flower garden
flower garden [Read More]

» travis credit union from travis credit union
travis credit union [Read More]

» dsl internet from dsl internet
dsl internet [Read More]

» internet telephony from internet telephony
internet telephony [Read More]

» tickets from tickets
tickets [Read More]

» cheap flights paris from cheap flights paris
cheap flights paris [Read More]

» ebay australia from ebay australia
ebay australia [Read More]

» cartoon porn from cartoon porn
cartoon porn [Read More]

» holidayinn from holidayinn
holidayinn [Read More]

Comments (2)

Let's see...

Perspective II (raise taxes) = E) the local Catholic archbishop.

Which is ridiculous. Therefore, I predict that the identity behind Perspective I must be equally ridiculous:

Perspective II = A) chair of the state democratic party.

Do I get a prize?

sniemann:

I think the first perspective is from the head of a middle-class household. And if not, it so easily could have been. We middle-class Christians have first-hand knowledge of the burden that high taxes pose. The first year we were married and filing jointly, John and I got whopped with such a large amount we had to pay, it took us two years to pay it all off. Aside from giving to the Church we had little left over. And then when our first child was born and we tried living on one income -- fuhgeddaboudit.

Unfortunately, I agree with veritas that the second perspective probably came from a local bishop. It shows a sadly pessimistic view of what lay people can and would like to do, were they to have more of their own money. On the other hand, imagine what decades of hearing confessions does to one's outlook on human generosity. He probably knows better than we think we do what people might do if they took home more of their money instead of having it appropriated by the state.

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

About

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on February 14, 2005 5:34 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Welfare for All.

The next post in this blog is Poland Beats Back Abortion.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.

Powered by
Movable Type 3.34